AI Is Both Hero and Villain in the Battle for Privacy-First Advertising

How often have you heard someone say their phone is listening to them? The story typically goes, someone mentions a product or service they’ve never searched for and moments later, an ad for it appears on their screen. While studies on this phenomenon are scarce, one found that 45% of people in the UK believe their phone is eavesdropping on them.

The reality? Phones don’t need to listen in. There’s already enough behavioral data available to advertisers to target people accurately. This capability has fuelled a sense of paranoia, which should alarm the industry. Now, with the proliferation of artificial intelligence (AI), the risks are even more pronounced.

The decline of third-party cookies has dominated the digital advertising agenda for years, coinciding with a wider paradigm shift towards privacy-first advertising. Relying on outdated, cookie-based, behavioral advertising is not only increasingly ineffective — as it reaches a rapidly shrinking pool of consumers — but also harmful to trust. As ad clutter grows and audiences become more discerning, irrelevant or “creepy” ads lead to a loss of engagement.

Consumers today demand respect for their data and their concerns are especially pressing given AI’s ability to map patterns at tremendous scale. By piecing together pieces of data that, in isolation, might be consented to and safe but, in combination, allow individual identification, AI-powered behavioral advertising can dance over privacy red lines. The cookie conversation seems quaint now; today the focus must turn to building a transparent, privacy-focused advertising ecosystem.

Related:AI and Customer Communications: A Matter of Trust

While AI has the potential to compound privacy concerns, other applications of the technology can support it, particularly through the use of contextual targeting. Instead of relying on personal data, contextual AI can identify patterns in content and how it’s consumed, creating highly relevant ads without a byte of user data.

Contextual AI can analyze text, images and even videos, ensuring ads are placed in environments where they naturally fit. This method mimics the advertising model that kept print media afloat for decades, allowing advertisers to reach consumers based on what they are engaging with, now in real-time.

Unlike cookie-based methods, contextual AI operates without collecting personal information, delivering effective results for brands while respecting privacy. This approach has the added benefit of creating positive perceptions without the risk of user mischaracterization inherent — and common — in behavioral targeting.

Related:AI Trainers and Prompters: The Hottest New White-Collar Job

Epsilon research found that 82% of consumers view a brand positively when its ads are relevant to their needs, while 76% view a brand negatively if targeting information is clearly incorrect, which occurred to an incredible 91% of respondents every single day.

The advertising industry must pursue data minimization to avoid feeding more personally identifiable data into opaque AI algorithms. While advertising is just one piece of the puzzle, it offers a clear path toward rebuilding consumer trust in the digital ecosystem, which will be under renewed pressure in the AI age.